If you read the other, background article on p. 4, you get much more information, including the somehow amusing fact that the government informed Abitibi of its plans by e-mail. Also that Williams claims Abitibi has reneged on its side of the 1905 (!) contract it had with the government.
The Premier quoted century-old documents to the legislature. He cited a 1903 letter from the president of the Anglo-Newfoundland Development Company Limited, a predecessor to AbitibiBowater, and a 1905 lease agreement to argue that the company's rights were dependent on operating a mill in the province.But neither article bothers to investigate the content of Williams' claims and work out whether they're true or not. So, though it certainly warms the heart to see a corporate hack that angry, there's absolutely no way for the reader to figure out the rights and wrongs here. (It does seem suggestive that they can't find a single Newfoundlander to quote as opposed to Williams' plan, not even the heads of the other major local employers.) The Globe knows what it wants you to think -- so much so that they're prepared to pass off the editorial as the news story and cut the news story down to a useless add-on.
UPDATE: Heh heh, about half the letters to the editor today are complaints about that dumb story. Well, you heard it here first.
No comments:
Post a Comment